Title of Dataset:
Contextualised Accent Bias in Professional Hierarchies, Study 2 – Evaluations of UK Legal Professional Candidates

Creators:
Yang Ye, University of Greenwich
Carol Withey, University of Greenwich

Date of Data Collection:
2022

Geographic Coverage:
United Kingdom

⸻

Contact:
y.ye@greenwich.ac.uk


⸻

Description of the Study

This dataset contains responses from a study examining how UK law students evaluate a legal professional candidate when the candidate speaks in different English accents. The study focuses on whether evaluations vary across legal roles, sub-sectors (corporate vs. criminal law), and career levels (trainee, solicitor, barrister, senior barrister). The study forms part of a larger research program on contextualised accent bias within professional hierarchies.

Participants listened to two audio recordings of a candidate answering interview-style questions in one of two accents: Received Pronunciation (RP) or Multicultural London English (MLE). After listening, participants provided general evaluations of the candidate, rated the candidate’s likelihood of receiving appointments in legal roles across two sub-sectors, completed accent perception ratings, answered attention-check questions, and reported demographic information.

Data were collected online using Qualtrics. Audio recordings were performed by professional actors. Ethical approval was granted by the Psychology and Counselling Research Ethics Committee, University of Greenwich.

⸻

Dataset Structure

The dataset is provided in UTF-8 CSV format (study2_data.csv).
Each row represents one participant.

Variables include:

• Screening and consent
• General evaluations of the candidate
• Legal role likelihood ratings for corporate and criminal sectors
• Two attention check questions
• Accent perception ratings
• Demographics and background information

A full codebook with item wording is available in:
study2_codebook.csv

⸻

Variable Groups

General evaluations (Q53–Q57)
Ratings of answer quality, intelligence, friendliness, overall impression, and willingness to work with the candidate.

Corporate law evaluations (Q58_1–Q58_6)
Likelihood of receiving appointments from trainee roles through QC/Senior barrister roles (1 = Extremely unlikely to 7 = Extremely likely).

Criminal law evaluations (Q59_1–Q59_6)
Parallel items assessing likelihood of receiving appointments in criminal law roles.

Attention checks
• Q61 – Degree classification check
• Q62 – Recording-content check

Accent Perception items (Q66_1–Q66_6)
Familiarity, similarity, liking, friendliness, and prestige of the accent.

Demographics (Q77–Q90)
Gender, age, ethnicity, region grown up in, postcode segment, native-language status, parental occupation, school type, university year, field of study, importance of study, and university.

⸻

File List
	1.	study2_data.csv – UTF-8 encoded dataset
	2.	study2_codebook.csv – Full ASCII-safe codebook
	3.	study2_survey.pdf – Qualtrics survey instrument
	4.	README_study2.txt – This documentation file

⸻

Methodology Summary

Participants were recruited from UK law programmes and completed the study online. All participants were at least 18 years old, living in the UK.

Procedure:
	1.	Screening and consent
	2.	Sound check
	3.	Listening to two interview recordings (accent condition)
	4.	General evaluation ratings
	5.	Legal role likelihood judgments across corporate and criminal law
	6.	Accent perception ratings
	7.	Attention checks
	8.	Demographics

Estimated completion time: 15-20 minutes.

⸻

Encoding and Compatibility

• Data are provided in UTF-8 CSV for maximum interoperability.
• Codebook uses plain ASCII for compatibility with UK Data Service ingestion.
• Files can be opened in R, Python, Stata, SPSS, Excel, and text editors.

⸻

Citation

Ye, Y., Withey, C., Sharma, D., & Levon, E. (2025). The Accent ceiling: Contextualised accent bias in professional hierarchies (Manuscript submitted for publication).